Q. Will I get sick from eating a burnt steak?
A. Yes. That is why one should become a vegan or, at the very least, a vegetarian.
The REAL answer: Mmm Mmm Good. The motto to Campbell’s soups should be applied to a big chunk of dead animal.
Lets take a look at how meat is composed before we get a straight answer. First, all meat is composed of water, connective tissue, fat tissue, and muscle. When a nice steak is heated up a lot of science is taking place. Collagen, a type of connective tissue, is the most abundant protein found in animal meat and converts to a gel when heated. This gelatin is the special component which makes Jell-O Jigglers jiggle. Another key element of meat is the fat, better known as marbling. When meat is being cooked the marbling melts and gives meat its juiciness and flavor. To see why meat turns brown, see the posting about cookies.
There is an invisible, intriguing reaction which happens when you see those gorgeous grill lines seared into the side of a steak. According to Brian Snyder, a student working on his doctorate in Human Nutrition at KSU, a cooked steak (or any other type of cooked meat for that matter) can be potentially hazardous due to the charring that forms on meats during grilling. During the high-temperature cooking heterocyclic amines are formed. These amines are carcinogenic to the body and are related to cancer. They are, however, not present in raw meat. Snyder said although risk is increased with this exposure, it does not necessarily mean cancer will develop. It could take many years before any symptoms show. In fact, someone should worry about the issues that will undoubtedly arise when undercooked meat is consumed. The risk of getting sick from eating undercooked meat is substantially greater (almost guaranteed) than the risk of developing cancer from overcooked meat.
Will you get sick from eating a burnt steak? No. Absolutely not. Can you get sick? Maybe.
Bourbon Beef Tenderloin
1 Cup red wine vinegar
1 Cup olive oil
1 Cup Evan Williams bourbon
1 beef tenderloin
3 Tablespoons cracked black pepper
Combine red wine vinegar, olive oil and bourbon.
Massage mixture into the beef with your hands.
Marinate the beef tenderloin in the refrigerator for one hour, any longer may cause the meat to become too tart.
Remove the meat from the marinade and pat dry. Coat the tenderloin with the cracked black pepper evenly and place marinated beef tenderloin in a roasting pan, place in oven and cook for 20 minutes in a 400 degree oven (or longer, depending on how you like your beef).
Let stand for 10 minutes.
Courtesy of the Evan Williams Cooking With Bourbon cookbook.